AN OTTOMAN SUCCESSOR TO ALISHER NAVOI IN DIDACTIC WISDOM LITERATURE
Keywords:
Alisher Navoi, Abdullatif Latifi, “Nazm ul-javahir”, “Nasr ul-la’ali”, Hazrat Ali, aphorisms, comparative analysis, Turkic literature, moral-didactic literature, rubai, masnavi, artistic interpretation, translationAbstract
This article presents a comparative and typological analysis of Alisher Navoi’s “Nazm ul-javahir” and the Ottoman poet Abdullatif Latifi’s “Nazmi javahir.” The main objective of the study is to identify the ideological and artistic features of these works, which were created on the basis of the collection of aphorisms “Nasr ul-la’ali” attributed to Hazrat Ali ibn Abu Talib, as well as to reveal their similarities and differences.
Particular attention is paid to the circumstances of the works’ creation, their sources, compositional structure, poetic form, and artistic style. The study also examines the poetic interpretation of Hazrat Ali’s sayings, their moral-didactic essence, and expressive devices.
The findings demonstrate that Alisher Navoi aims at a more comprehensive coverage of the aphorisms, elaborating them in the form of musarra’ rubai, whereas Abdullatif Latifi prefers a selective translation approach, emphasizing brevity and clarity through the use of masnavi couplets. In both works, the key themes include Islamic ethics, knowledge, justice, patience, and human perfection.
The comparative analysis reveals that Navoi’s literary tradition had a significant influence on Ottoman Turkish literature, clearly reflected in Latifi’s work. At the same time, both texts transcend the boundaries of translation and represent independent artistic interpretations. The results of the study contribute to understanding the development of the tradition of versifying aphoristic wisdom in Turkic literature.
References
Alisher Navoiy. Nazm ul-javohir / To‘la asarlar to‘plami. 10 jildlik. 10-jild. – Toshkent: G‘afur G‘ulom nomidagi NMIU, 2011.
Alisher Navoiy. Mezon ul-avzon / To‘la asarlar to‘plami. 10 jildlik. 10-jild. – Toshkent: G‘afur G‘ulom nomidagi NMIU, 2011.
Алишер Навоий: қомусий луғат. – Тошкент: Шарқ НМК, 2016.
Altunağa, Ahmet. Mustafa bin Şücâ’nın Nesrü’l-leâlî Şerhi
(İnceleme- Metin), Manisa Celal Bayar Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler
Enstitüsü, Yüksek Lisans Tezi, 2019.
Бойқаро, Ҳусайн. Рисола. – Тошкент: Шарқ, 1991.
Брокельман, Карл. История арабской литературы. В нескольких томах. Т. 1. 1897.
Ceyhan, Âdem – Aydoğan T. Sultan II. Murad İçin Dizilmiş
İnciler: Hâfız’ın Nesrü’l-leâlî Tercümesi (Lü’lü’-i Mendûd), Turkish
Studies - International Periodical For The Languages, Literature and
History of Turkish or Turkic Volume 8/13 Fall 2013, p.p. 37-73.
Ceyhan, Adem – Ekinci, Ramazan. Latîfî’nin Nesrü’l-leâlî Tercümesi: Nazm-ı Cevâhir // Divan Edebiyatı Araştırmaları Dergisi 25, İstanbul 2020, 79-190.
Жирмунский, Bиктор. Сравнительное литературоведение. Восток и Запад. Избр. труды. ‒ М.: Наука, 1979.
Latifi. Tezkiretü’ş-Şu’arâ ve Tabsıratü’n-Nuzamâ (hazırlayan: Rıdvan Canım). – Ankara, 2018.
Одинаев, Абуҳалим. Пандномаи «Сад Калима»-и Рашидуддин Ватвот муаррифгари адабиёти тоҷик дар ҷаҳон // ОСИЁ ВА АВРУПО
(мачаллаи илми). – Душанбе, 2024. № 3 (19).
Özkan, Ferudun. Mâtemî’nin Nesrü’l-Le’âlî Tercümesi. Türk Kültürü ve Hacı Bektaş-ı Veli Araştırmaları Dergisi, 2019, Güz, S. 91, s.107-146.
Sevgi, Ahmet. Latifi: Hayoti va asarlari (Doktorlik dissertatsiyasi). Gazi Universiteti, 1987.
Ражабова, Маърифат. Алишер Навоийнинг шеърий дурдонаси / Истиқлол даври ўзбeк навоийшунослиги: 30 жилдлик. 26-жилд. – Тошкeнт: Tamaddun, 2021.
Рашидова, Маъмура. Алишeр Навоий “Назм ул-жавоҳир” асарининг матний тадқиқоти. – Тошкeнт, 2011.
Yusupova, Dilnavoz. Abdullatif Latifiyning “Tazkirat ush-shuaro” asarida Navoiyga ergashgan shoirlar zikri // O‘zbekiston: Til va madaniyat, 2025. Vol.3. – B. 5-16.
Yusupova, Dilnavoz. Alisher Navoiy va Muslihiddin Mustafo Axtariyning “Arba’in” asarlari / Sharq mumtoz adabiyoti: talqin va tahlillar (Monografiya). – Istanbul: Babıali kültür yayıncılığı, 2025.