NATURAL LAW THEORIES AS AN IDEOLOGICAL BASIS FOR INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS: ARE THEY PRESENT IN NATIONAL LEGISLATION?
Keywords:
Natural law theories, intellectual property objects, commercialization, Theory of Immaterial Goods, Fair Use Doctrine, First Sale Doctrine, Moral Rights DoctrineAbstract
The article analyzes the significance of economic and legal doctrines based on natural law theories in regulating social relations related to intellectual property objects. It substantiates how these theories serve as an ideological foundation for the commercialization of intellectual property and the establishment of its legal regime. The author examines approaches based on natural law and incentive theories through examples from national legislation and international practices. The study concludes with the author’s position on the matter.
References
F. Scott Kieff, Property Rights and Property Rules for Commercializing Inventions, 85 Minn. L. Rev. 697 (2001).
Гхош Ш. Имплементация доктрины исчерпания прав: выводы, основанные на национальном опыте. (Ghosh S. Implementation of the doctrine of exhaustion of rights: conclusions based on national experience) Trade policy / 2015. № 4/4.
L. Donald Prutzman, Eric Stenshoel. The Exhaustion Doctrine in the United States. New York State Bar Association International Law and Practice Section Fall Meeting —2013 Hanoi, Vietnam. P. 2-3
М.С.Нургалеев. Понятие и принципы исчерпания исключительного права на товарный знак. Гуманитарные, социально-экономические и общественные науки, 2017. №3. (M.S. Nurgaleev. The concept and principles of exhaustion of the exclusive right to a trademark. Humanities, socio-economic and social sciences, 2017. No. 3)
Noreen Wiscovitch Rentas, Moral Rights Exclusion in the North American Free Trade Agreement and the General Agreement on Tariff and Trade: A Legal Proposal for the Inclusion of Moral Rights in Future Free Trade Agreements in Latin America and the Caribbean, 35 REV. DER. P.R. 97 (1996).
DIEGO ESPÍN CÁNOVAS, MANUAL DE DERECHO CIVIL ESPAÑOL, DERECHOS REALES, VOLUME 2, 392-398 (7th ed. 1985).
Elizabeth Schéré. Where is the Morality? Moral Rights in International Intellectual Property and Trade Law. Fordham International Law Journal. Volume 41, Issue 3 2018 Article 6.
See, for example, Justin Hughes, "The Philosophy of Intellectual Property," Georgetown Law Journal 77 (1988): 287, at 299-330. These initial impressions are examined in more detail in part III, below.
Niels van Dijk. A Conflict-Based Approach to Intellectual Rights. Monograph Book. Published: 28 Jul 2017. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781786432506
Kohler, J. (1894). Die Idee des geistigen Eigentums. AcP, 32, 99−167
Kohler, J. (1880). Das Autorrecht. Jena: Verlag von Gustav Fischer
Kohler, J. (1900). Handbuch des deutschen Patentrechts in rechtsvergleichender Darstellung. Mannheim: J. Bensheimer Verlag
О.А.Куликов. Добросовестное использование объектов авторского права. Москва – 2021. (O.A.Kulikov. Fair use of copyrighted works. Moscow – 2021)
Copyright Law of the United States and Related Laws Contained in Title 17 of the United States Code. // URL: https://www.copyright.gov/title17/title17.pdf
Луткова О.В. “Доктрина добросовестного использования произведений в современном авторском праве США” // Право. Журнал Высшей школы экономики. 2016. № 2. С. 186–199. (Lutkova O.V. “Fair Use doctrine of works in modern US copyright law” // Law. Journal of the Higher School of Economics. 2016. No. 2. pp. 186–199)
Абдулманнон Абдуллоҳ. Тижорат ва ишлаб чиқариш ҳақида тасаввур – Т.: “Hilol-Nashr”, 2022. (Abdulmannon Abdullah. A vision of trade and production - T.: "Hilal-Nashr", 2022.)
