SOCIAL NECESSITY AND PRACTICAL IMPORTANCE OF THE PRINCIPLE OF COMPETITION IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS

Authors

  • Seytnazarov Kurbanbay Reyimbaevich

Keywords:

criminal procedure, the principle of competition, justice, procedural equality, judicial and legal reforms, defense and prosecution, procedural guarantees, independence of courts

Abstract

This article analyses the social necessity of the principle of competition in criminal proceedings, as
well as its legal and practical aspects. The essence of the principle of contention, its mechanisms of
implementation and role in judicial proceedings are considered as the subject of research. The aim of
the article is to identify ways to improve the effectiveness of the application of the principle of
adversarial in criminal proceedings and to develop proposals for strengthening its legal basis. The
study details the importance of this principle in criminal proceedings, ensuring legal equality of
parties and the impact of competition on achieving fair justice. In the process of work used
comparative legal analysis, observation, generalization, methods of induction and deduction. The
results of the study show that the full implementation of the principle of competition contributes to a
fair hearing of criminal cases and protection of the rights of the parties. Legal and organizational
problems that prevent the full implementation of this principle in judicial practice have also been
identified and measures proposed to eliminate them. The findings can be used to ensure the rights and
freedoms of participants in criminal proceedings, improve the judicial system and reform legislation.
Finally, the need to ensure equality of the parties and strengthen the independence of the courts for
the effective functioning of the principle of competition is stressed.

References

Oʻzbekiston Respublikasi Prezidentining Farmoni, 12.05.2018-yildagi PF-5441-son.

https://lex.uz/ru/docs/-3731060 (Decree of the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan dated

05.2018 No. UP-5441. https://lex.uz/ru/docs/-3731060)

Oʻzbekiston Respublikasi Prezidentining qarori, 30.05.2022-yildagi PQ-263-son.

https://lex.uz/docs/-6039334 (Resolution of the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan dated May

, 2022 No. PP-263. https://lex.uz/docs/-6039334)

“Jinoyat va jinoyat-protsessual qonunchiligi tizimini tubdan takomillashtirish chora-tadbirlari

toʻgʻrisida” Oʻzbekiston Respublikasi Prezidentining qarori. https://lex.uz/mact/-3735818

(Resolution of the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan "On Measures for Fundamental

Improvement of the System of Criminal and Criminal Procedure Legislation." https://lex.uz/mact/-

Шумилова Л.Ф. Принципы состязательности и объективной истины как фундаментальные

начала правоприменительной практики // Журнал рос. права, 2015. № 11. С. 52. (Shumilova

L.F. Principles of adversarial proceedings and objective truth as fundamental principles of law

enforcement practice // Journal of Russian Law, 2015. No 11. P. 52.)

Бурмaгин С.В. Метaмoрфoзы сoстязaтельнoсти угoлoвных прoизвoдств пo делaм

судебнoгo кoнтрoля. Тoм 73 № 2 (159). МГЮA.М.,2020. (Burmagin S.V. Metamorphoses of

adversarial proceedings in cases of judicial control. Volume 73, No. 2 (159). MGYUA.M., 2020.)

Л.В.Виницкий. Ю.Л.Бурнoсoвa. Прaвилoнепoсредственнoсти в

спрaведливoмугoлoвнoмсудoпрoизвoдстве. ВестникЮУрГУ. Серия «Прaвo». 2019. Т. 19, № 3,

С. 10–15 (Bulletin of the South Ural State University. 12 Ser. Law. 2019, vol. 19, no. 3, рр. 10–15).

(Vinitskiy, L.V. Yu.L. Burnosova. Law Enforcement in Fair Criminal Proceedings. Herald of

Urgench State University. Series "Law." 2019. Vol. 19, No. 3, P. 10-15 (Bulletin of the South Ural

State University. 12 Sir. Law. 2019, vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 10-15))

Алтынникова Лиля Игоревна. Кандидат юридик наук. Особенности состязателного

характера апелляционного производства по делам о применении принудителных мер

медицинского характера. М.МГЮА. Вестникуниверситета. 2018. 172 - 179. (Altynnikova Lilya

Igorevna. Candidate of Legal Sciences. Features of the adversarial nature of appellate proceedings in

cases concerning the application of compulsory medical measures. M.MGYUA. University Bulletin.

pp. 172-179.)

В.В. Кузнецoв. Рoльсудa в сoстязaтельнoмпрoцессе. ИзвестияВузoв. 2011.92-95. (V.V.

Kuznetsov. Rolsuda v sostyazatelnom protsesse. IzvestiyaVuzov. 2011. pp. 92-95.)

Строгович М.С. Курс советского уголовного процесса. Том 1. Основные положения науки

советского уголовного процесса. М.: Издательство «Наука», 1968. С. 149-150.( Strogovich M.S.

Course of the Soviet Criminal Procedure. Volume 1. Basic provisions of the science of Soviet

criminal procedure. Moscow: Nauka Publishing House, 1968. P. 149-150.)

Muhitdinov F.M. Jinoyat ishlarining sud muhokamasida tortishuvchilik рrinsiрini amalga

oshirish muammolari. Yuridik fanlar nomzodi ilmiy darajasini olish uchun dissertatsiya. Toshkent.

B.20-23 b. (Mukhitdinov F.M. Problems of implementing the principle of adversarial

proceedings in criminal proceedings. Dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Legal Sciences.

Tashkent. 1999. P. 20-23.)

O‘zbekiston Resрublikasi Bosh Рrokuraturasining tergov faoliati bo‘yicha “1-Ya” hisoboti.

(Report "1-Ya" on the investigative activities of the Prosecutor General's Office of the Republic of

Uzbekistan.)

S.A. Tumashov “Прaвилoнепoсредственнoсти в

спрaведливoмугoлoвнoмсудoпрoизвoдстве. ВестникЮУрГУ. Серия “Прaвo”. 2019. Т. (S.A.

Tumashov "Rules of Mediation in Fair Criminal Proceedings. Herald of Urgench State University.

Series "Law." 2019. Vol.)

Курбанов Ш. ЖИНОЯТ ПРОЦЕССИЛА ТАРАФЛАРНИНГ ТОРТИШУВЧАНЛИГИ:

ХОРИЖ ТАЖРИБАСИ //Development of pedagogical technologies in modern sciences. – 2022. –

Т. 1. – №. 2. – С. 80-84.( Kurbanov Sh. COMPETITIVENESS OF THE PARTIES IN CRIMINAL

PROCESS: FOREIGN EXPERIENCE //Development of pedagogical technologies in modern

sciences. - 2022. - Vol. 1. - No. - Б. 80-84.)

RahmonovaS. Текст научной работы на тему Перспективы усиления принципа

состязательности на стадии направления уголовного дела к судебному разбирательству //O

‘zbekistonqonunchiligitahlili. – 2015. – №. 1. – С. 57-60. (RakhmonovaS. The text of the scientific

work on the topic "Prospects for strengthening the principle of adversarial proceedings at the stage of

sending a criminal case for judicial review" //Analysis of the legislation of Uzbekistan. - 2015. - No.

- P. 57-60.)

Щербаков В. А. Cостязательность уголовного судопроизводства: роль суда в ее

обеспечении. электронный научный журнал Байкальского государственного университета. -

Baikal Research Journal - 2016. DOI 10.17150/2411-6262.2016.7(5).17.(Sherbakov V. A.

Consistency of Criminal Proceedings: The Role of the Court in its Provision. electronic scientific

journal of Baikal State University. - Bakhal Research Journal - 2016. DOI 10.17150/2411-

2016.7 (5).17.)

Odilqoriyev X. T. Sud hokimyatining mustaqilligi va daxlsizligi – fuqarolar huquqlarini

ishonchli ta'minlash kafolati. BPAA.2020.6-11b. №1(41).( Odilkoriev Kh.T. Independence and

Integrity of the Judicial Authority - a Guarantee of Reliable Ensuring of Citizens' Rights.

BPAA.2020.6-11b. No. 1 (41))

Камардина Анжела Анатольевна. Роль суда в обеспечении состязательности и

равноправия сторон при рассмотрении уголовного дела судом первой инстанции. 2014.

ИОГАУ. Правовые науке. 250-252. (Kamardina Angela Anatolyevna. The role of the court in

ensuring adversarial proceedings and equality of the parties in the consideration of a criminal case by

the court of first instance. 2014. IOGAU. Legal Sciences. 250-252.)

Липский Н.А., Копенкина Л.А. К вопросу о реализации принципа состязательности и

равноправия сторон в уголовном процессе. Ученые записки СПб филиала РТА № 2 (70) 2019.(

Lipsky N.A., Kopenkina L.A. On the issue of implementing the principle of adversarial proceedings

and equality of the parties in criminal proceedings. Scientific notes of the SPb branch of RTA No 2

(70) 2019.)

Петрухин И.Л. Состязательность и правосудие (к 100-летию М.С. Строговича) //

Государство и право. 1994. № 10. С. 130.(Petrukhin I.L. Compliance and Justice (for the 100th

anniversary of M.S. Strogovich) // State and Law. 1994. No. 10. P. 130)

Фойницкий И.Я. Курс уголовного судопроизводства. СПб., 1996. С. 64. (Foynitsky I.Ya.

Course of Criminal Proceedings. St. Petersburg, 1996. P. 64.)

Бурмагин С. В. Метаморфозы состязательности уголовных производств по делам

судебного контроля. МГЮА. НАУКИ КРИМИНАЛЬНОГО ЦИКЛА. Том 73 № 2 (159)

февраль 2020. (Burmagin S. V. Metamorphoses of the adversarial nature of criminal proceedings in

cases of judicial control. MGYUA. SCIENCES OF THE CRIMINAL CYCLE. Volume 73 No 2 (159

February 2020))

https://stat.uz/uz/rasmiy-statistika/crime-and-justice-2

Published

2025-07-19